When it comes to producing superb Neapolitan-style pies at home, there is just no substitute for a good pizza stone. Using a standard baking sheet typically results in one of three things: a) a burnt crust, b) a soggy bottom or c) an unevenly cooked mixture of the two. Fortunately, pizza stones are widely available, moderately affordable, and simple to use for consistently excellent pizza whenever you have a craving.
Top 10 Best Pizza Stones for Cooking Surface in 2021
So, whether you’re new to pizza-making or looking to improve your skills, here are our top recommendations for the best pizza stones available on the market. The greatest pizza stones on the market. The Pizzacraft 16.5-Inch ThermaBond Pizza Stone is the most adaptable. For gas grills, Hans Grill is the finest option.
- For BBQ smokers, the Unicook Heavy Duty Ceramic Pizza Grilling Stone is the ideal option.
- The CastElegance Pizza Stone is ideal for creating a crispy crust.
- The finest nonstick set is the NeoCasa Black Cordierite Pizza Stone Set.
- For ovens, the Honey-Can-Do Rectangular Pizza Stone is excellent.
- The greatest dishwasher-safe pizza stone is the Emile Henry Flame Top Pizza Stone.
- The NerdChef Steel Stone is an expensive item Pizza Baking Surface.
- The finest present is the Ritual Life Pizza Stone for the Oven and Grill.
- The Smokin’ Stone Jr. Pizza Stone by Char-Griller is excellent for Kamado grills.
What to Consider
First, consider your cooking method. Do you need a pizza stone alternative only for the oven, or will you use it on your new gas barbeque or kamado grill as well? Alternatively, if you have loftier aspirations and want to invest in an outdoor pizza oven, you may require a more expensive pizza stone. The most popular materials used to manufacture pizza stones are ceramic, cordierite, cast iron, and steel. Ceramic is often the least expensive material, although nowadays you can frequently find a longer-lasting cordierite pizza stone of equal quality for a comparable price.
Ceramic pizza stones require the most time to heat up and are prone to cracking or chipping, although they are lighter than other materials and usually come with metal serving racks to transfer the pizza from oven to table. Cordierite pizza stones are more costly but also last longer.
These stones can withstand extremely high temperatures but must be warmed for around 30 minutes. They’re ideal for baking or grilling crispy crust pizza. Steel and cast iron alternatives (more pizza pan than stone, to be precise) are typically more costly, but they are more flexible and produce crisp crusts at lower temperatures. They have the drawback of being heavy and difficult to remove from the oven.
How We Made Our Decision
Our selection includes pizza stones in a range of materials and sizes, all of which have received four-star reviews or above. We went through many customer evaluations and contacted professional sources such as Good Housekeeping and Epicurious while doing our study. We included top-quality options at all price ranges, ranging from value-packed pizza stone sets that make great welcome presents to high-end splurges for real pizza expert aficionados.
1. Pizzacraft 16.5-Inch ThermaBond Pizza Stone
At around $40 at the time of writing, this popular large pizza stone works equally well in the oven and on the grill, making it a good bargain. The huge 16.5-inch circular stone can cook enough pizza for four households. It can endure temperatures of 900 degrees Fahrenheit since it is made of the brand’s unique ThermaBond material, which is cordierite with additional toughness to avoid breakage. Because the porous substance absorbs soap, it is merely cleaned with water and a brush.
2. Hans Grill Pizza Stone
If you intend to cook pizza on your gas barbecue, look no further than Hans Grill’s pizza stone. It’s made with a thick slab of cordierite, which holds heat well to make a light and crispy crust while collecting moisture beneath the pie as it cooks and cools. It comes with a wooden pizza paddle, which is a great addition, and it’s also available in a round stone, though you might find that the one we’re featuring here is easier to work with on a rectangular grill grate.
3. Unicook Heavy Duty Ceramic Pizza Grilling Stone
Unicook’s heavy-duty pizza cordierite pizza stone substitute can withstand temperatures of up to 1,450°F, making it ideal for use on grill smokers on a low setting for quick, precisely cooked pizza. It may also be used in any oven and makes enough slices to serve the entire family. It weighs more than 6 pounds and may darken with usage, although this has no effect on the flavor of the pizza. It includes a pizza dough scraper for cleaning after use. Remember not to use any pre-cooking oil or soap while washing.
4. CastElegance large Pizza Stone
CastElegance is a well-known firm headquartered in the United States that manufactures pizza stones for oven that make pies with a crispy crust. To make all of its pizza stones, the company uses its unique Thermarite substance, which is essentially a mineral mixture dominated by cordierite. They are quite resilient and do an excellent job of retaining heat and absorbing moisture. This huge rectangular stone may be used in the oven or on a gas or charcoal grill, and it comes with a cleaning scraper and a recipe e-book.
5. NeoCasa Black Cordierite Pizza Stone Set
This value-packed kit has everything a pizza-making novice needs to get started, and the gorgeous packaging makes it an ideal present. The set comes with a big stone with a nonstick coating that can be used in the oven or on a gas or charcoal grill, as well as a thick wood paddle for sliding out the piping-hot pizza to slice up with the pizza blade. There’s also a 30-recipe e-cookbook with tips on how to make the ideal pie.
6. Honey-Can-Do Rectangular Pizza Stone for oven
One of the things we like best about this pizza stone is that it is lightweight and large enough to cover the majority of the grade, reducing the possibility of cheese pouring over the edges and clinging to the oven. It’s also a consumer favorite, with an average rating of 4.5 stars from over 3,800 reviews. The cordierite stone is composed of a lead-free clay combination that holds and distributes heat evenly, and it has raised edges on the bottom to make it easier to pull out of the oven.
7. Emile Henry Flame Top Pizza Stone for oven
Emile Henry has been producing quality cookware and bakeware since 1850, and this pizza stone is no exception. The ceramic pizza stone is dishwasher-friendly, making it easier to clean than cordierite alternatives. Furthermore, it may be used on any grill, including wood-burning ones, giving your pizza a delicious, smoky flavor. It can resist temperatures as high as 900 degrees Fahrenheit.
8. NerdChef Steel Stone Pizza Baking Surface
If you want to spend, it’s difficult to match this sturdy steel alternative from Portland, Oregon-based NerdShelf. While it is more pizza pan than stone, it has remarkable heat conductivity—20 times that of ceramic, according to the company’s website—and it stays hot in the oven, allowing you to crank out several pizzas like a professional chef. It is seasoned with flaxseed oil to prevent rust, cleans up easily with water and a non-abrasive scrubber, and has a lifetime warranty. The only drawback is that it weighs a whopping 23 pounds.
9. Ritual Life Pizza Stone for Oven and Grill
This set is a showstopper, featuring a beautiful acacia wood peel, a stainless steel pizza blade with a bamboo handle, and a serving tray. The big cordierite pizza stone takes up plenty of oven or gas grill space for one large or two little pies and can withstand temperatures of up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit. The stainless steel serving plate may also be used in the oven. The pizza blade is protected by a cover, and the wood peel is beautiful enough to be used as a standard cutting board and hung in the kitchen.
10. Char-Griller Smokin’ Stone Jr. Pizza Stone
If you’ve chosen to treat yourself to a kamado grill this summer, a pizza stone insert is one of several must-have extras. This one is designed to work with Char-Griller kamados, but grills come in a variety of sizes, so it may also work with other manufacturers. The pizza stone is constructed of cordierite and is designed to allow heat to rise from the edge of the grill chamber for even and quick cooking. The stone can endure temperatures of up to 800° F.